Treadmill vs Cycling (Stationary) | Which Is Better?

Treadmill Vs Cycling

When planning on purchasing a piece of cardio equipment for completing your workout regime, you should select it carefully as per your requirements, goals, and preferences. No two different types of cardio equipment are designed alike.

Each has its advantages and disadvantages, so having in-depth knowledge about them may direct you along the proper route. So, if you’re looking to get started with a fitness routine but aren’t sure where to start, you have come to the right place.

Looking to get your fitness regimen started but aren’t sure where to start? Or asking what’s the best for you, treadmill vs cycle? Or if both of the equipment developed equally with regard to their fitness benefits? Let me tell you the answer is No and Yes as well.

Both devices are not precisely the same but have comparable advantages. Having said that, they also have their differences. Therefore, understanding more about treadmill vs cycling will help you make the most informed decision. Here’s all you need to know.

Treadmill Vs Cycling

1. Calorie And Fat Burning Capacity

Calorie and fat burn is the first thing that comes to our mind when talking about a fitness routine. It is a fact that for losing weight, you need to burn calories more than you consume them. The longer you can burn calories in a specific time frame, the more beneficial the workout is. In this case, the treadmill has the upper hand. 

The reason being, with a treadmill, you may burn up to 600-700 calories each hour, as long as you jog or walk at a higher incline at a rapid rate. Whereas you can only burn about 400 calories/hour or a maximum of 500 calories/hour with a cycle if you are exercising at an intense rate.

You can get decent results from either of them if fat loss is what you want. The treadmill, nonetheless, is an inch ahead. If you run or walk at a brisk pace or do a steeply inclined walk on a treadmill, you are going to burn more calories than you would with a cycle. It’s normal to find people losing 10-20 cal/min by running very fast or 8-10 cal/min by walking on a steep incline briskly. 

Intensive riding generally means losing 8-10 calories per minute when considering cycling. To achieve 10-12 calories per minute, you would have to work very hard at a very high degree of resistance; therefore, this will just be out of reach for many individuals. The normal cyclist will lose a little less than that, i.e., 3-5 cal/minute. Cycling does not burn as many calories as jogging at the same effort since you sit there while cycling. Overall stability muscles are therefore less involved. Hence, if you want to focus on burning calories, we would recommend buying one of the best treadmill in India.

2. Ease Of Use

Ease Of Use - Treadmill Vs Cycling

If we consider the ease of use, since both of these workout techniques require you to perform natural movements that you keep doing time and again, there are no significant distinctions. However, most people take a bit longer to get used to the belt moving beneath them on the treadmill. Whereas the cycle is merely a hop-on and gets started kind of machine. Hence, no learning curve is present in the case of cycles. But we cannot ignore the fact that both machines are highly user-friendly and are ideal for beginners and advanced trainees.

3. Price

Budget is one of the most important factors to consider while purchasing anything. And when we are talking about treadmill vs cycling, total machine costs are greater for the treadmills. Even though you can go for an expensive cycle that costs more than a lower model treadmill, you’ll find the treadmill is the pricier of the two. So if you desire inexpensive fitness, buying an exercise cycle is your best bet.

4. Durability Of The Machine

When investing in something, you would want it to last long. Hence, this is yet again an essential point to think about when confused between treadmill vs cycle. The machine’s longevity should be considered, as regular repairs may be pretty pricey on the machine, which would affect the overall price of the machine. 

You would undoubtedly want to choose a cycle over a treadmill as treadmills tend to be more susceptible to wear and tear since additional parts and systems can become defective. There are chances that the belt present beneath may wear out, the motor may collapse, or the elevation mechanism may fail. So, in this case, cycles are hands down more durable than treadmills.

5. Variability In Workouts

Constant variation is a crucial factor in the continuous growth of your exercises. Essentially, you need to periodically modify things around you while you work out every day. If not, the body will adjust, and soon it will cease to respond entirely. Therefore, it would be prudent to maintain the status quo.

But in the battle of treadmill vs cycling, which machine offers the best variability? With cycles, you have the option to increase the pace at which you ride or the total resistance that you put into use. You can also do this with treadmills. In addition to increasing the pace, you can also increase the level of inclination of the belt. Both are excellent strategies to increase the program’s intensity and deliver outstanding outcomes.

6. Chances Of Injury

Treadmill Vs Cycling

How prone are you to injuries while working out on either of these 2 machines has to be taken into account? In the case of treadmills, along with high impact, there are high possibilities that you might lose your balance and ultimately fall off the treadmill. Another possibility is that you might sprain your ankle in case you stepped on your foot funny. However, these injuries are least expected with a cycle. But 3 main injury risks that you are likely to face on a stationary cycle are:

  • Butt pain caused by sitting for long hours.
  • Knee discomfort/pain caused by continuous rotation of the legs.
  • Shoulder or back pain caused by hunching over for long hours.

You can minimize the possibilities of sore knees by taking some days off during the week. In addition to this, correct posture and massages might also help release the discomfort from your neck and shoulders. However, the injuries caused by a treadmill are more severe and can’t be avoided. Thus, if injuries are your concern, choosing a stationary cycle instead of a treadmill will be better.

7. Strength Training

The obvious winner here is the cycle. In the case of treadmills, you add resistance only by increasing the inclination angle. This would just help to work on your calf muscles primarily. The best way to build muscles with a treadmill is sprint training. Sprint training involves intense workout sessions that will use your fast-twitch muscle fibers. 

This subsequently activates the maximum number of muscle-building hormones of your body. You end up having a chiseled physique, which is not possible by running on a treadmill alone. If we talk about cycling, it makes you work more against the resistance with each rep you do. So, even cycling proves to be quite good enough to build up the degree of your strength.

Conclusion

In the battle of treadmill vs cycle, we lean more towards the stationary cycle as it is user-friendly, budget-friendly, risk of injury is minimal, and has great durability. However, if your primary objective is calorie and fat loss, a treadmill would suit you the best. It would be better if you think wisely and purchase something that would suit your preferences and objectives.